NACP NACP
A-
A
A+
A
A
Звичайна версія сайту

Audit of the organisation of corruption prevention work in the State Judicial Administration: formal approach to the development of the anti-corruption programme and non-transparent procurement

27.03.2025
e76ab3671224562d93fe6f291b53b20136f74cbc19017e15fe8e95057095d197-900x400

The National Agency on Corruption Prevention (NACP) has completed a routine inspection of the organisation of work on preventing and detecting corruption in the activities of the State Judicial Administration of Ukraine (SJA).

The SJA is a government agency that provides organisational and financial support to the judiciary, which necessitates compliance with anti-corruption standards in its work.

The audit showed active work of the SJA's anti-corruption commissioner, who, in cooperation with the NACP, introduced a systematic approach to implementing anti-corruption policies in local (appellate) courts by introducing the work of anti-corruption commissioners appointed from among court employees.

At the same time, a number of shortcomings were identified that negatively affect the effectiveness of the anti-corruption policy implementation in the body.

NACP noted a formal approach to the development of the anti-corruption programme and the lack of proper analysis of the sources of corruption risks. The programme does not contain a detailed description of the mechanisms and components of these risks, which is a consequence of the lack of a systematic analysis of sources of information on corruption risks. In particular, this includes the analysis of court decisions in cases of criminal and administrative offences, as well as disciplinary and civil liability against SJA employees, reports of the State Audit Service of Ukraine and SJA internal audit, which indicate the existence of systemic violations in software procurement.

As a result, corruption risks in the activities of the SJA have remained unchanged for years, despite the periodic prosecution of its employees.

The following example illustrates the ineffectiveness of corruption risk management in the SJA.

In December 2022, the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU) completed a pre-trial investigation in criminal proceedings against the former head of one of the SJA departments and his accomplice, the head of a private company specialising, among other things, in the wholesale trade of computers, peripheral equipment and software. The investigation established that in 2016-2018, the defendants organised the procurement of equipment for the needs of the SJA, which, by its technical characteristics, did not meet the information security requirements that are mandatory when recording court proceedings. In total, according to the expert examinations, the SJA overpaid about UAH 53 million for the equipment supplied. Law enforcement also found out that the former official had legalised part of the proceeds of crime.

The results of this NABU investigation should have prompted the SJA to scrutinise the causes and conditions that contributed to the commission of a corruption offence related to procurement and to develop mechanisms to prevent the realisation of corruption risks.

An analysis of the results of public procurement by the SJA conducted by its territorial departments in 2023 shows that corruption risks in this area of the agency's activities continue to be implemented, effective measures to minimise them are not provided for in the anti-corruption programme of the agency, and the analysis of counterparties conducted by the authorised units of the SJA's territorial departments was superficial and did not prevent the conclusion of contracts with counterparties of doubtful reputation.

Thus, during the inspection, the NACP found that at the end of 2023, officials of the SJA and its territorial departments purchased equipment worth UAH 25 million from business entities that are related to the persons involved in the NABU investigation into the corruption offences mentioned above through their founders and participants.

At the same time, the procurement was carried out with restricted competition: the tender documentation included conditions that could only be fulfilled by a predetermined entity, which indicates a prior conspiracy and intent to commit corruption-related criminal offences.

The interest of the officials of the SJA territorial departments in winning the tenders of these legal entities is evidenced by the unlawful rejection of the offer of the procurement participant, which was confirmed by the decision of the Antimonopoly Committee (No. 332-r/pk-pz dated 05.01.2024).

Based on the results of the NACP's inspection, the Main Investigation Department of the National Police of Ukraine launched a pre-trial investigation into the fact that the SJA officials, together with the above legal entities, committed a corruption offence under Part 4 of Article 191 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (misappropriation, embezzlement or seizure of another's property by abuse of office).

If found guilty, the defendants in the case face imprisonment for a term of five to eight years with disqualification to hold certain positions or engage in certain activities for up to three years.

At the same time, based on the NACP's materials, the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine launched an investigation into possible anticompetitive concerted actions by the companies with which the territorial offices of the SJA entered into the above agreements.

The facts established by the NACP during the audit demonstrate the need to develop the anti-corruption infrastructure in the system of supporting the activities of the judicial branch of the SJA by introducing counterparty analysis, anti-corruption examination of contracts, qualitative research of the internal environment of the SJA and analysis of the mechanisms of committing corruption offences that are already the subject of court proceedings.

For reference.

The Law of Ukraine ‘On Prevention of Corruption ’ provides for the functioning of certain anti-corruption institutions, mechanisms and tools in public organisations designed to prevent corruption. These include, first and foremost, the activities of the authorised unit for the prevention and detection of corruption, the existence of an effective anti-corruption programme, a corruption risk management system and a whistleblowing institution, etc.

The proper functioning of these components of the anti-corruption system and ensuring their maximum efficiency are subject to scheduled and unscheduled inspections of the organisation of work on preventing and detecting corruption, conducted by the NACP pursuant to clause 52, part 1, article 12 of the Law of Ukraine ‘On Prevention of Corruption’ and the procedure approved by the NACP order.

Latest News

30.05.2025
13:56
Housing for Internally Displaced Persons: Deputy Head of NACP spoke about anti-corruption measures in this area
29.05.2025
16:31
A tax official in Ternopil region was notified of suspicion of providing false information in declarations worth over UAH 23 million based on NACP materials
15:15
Full audit of declarations by NACP: former head of Dnipro Medical and Social Expert Commission and former head of Ternopil Regional Council to be brought to trial for false declarations
12:15
SBI has notified a former migration officer from Odesa region of suspicion of false declaration based on NACP materials
27.05.2025
18:00
Full audits of declarations submitted by Territorial Centre for Recruitment and Social Support officials: 18 audits completed, violations worth UAH 36.8 million identified
26.05.2025
18:30
The International Monetary Fund supports the preservation and strengthening of the NACP's financial control measures for public officials
15:31
NACP presented a unified action plan to implement NATO recommendations on integrity in the security and defence sector
23.05.2025
18:30
Full audit of the declarations of the former deputy mayor of Dnipro: signs of illegal enrichment of over UAH 8 million and false information worth over UAH 47 million
22.05.2025
17:45
Full audit of the declaration of the former head of the Pension Fund Administration of Khmelnytskyi Region: signs of illegal enrichment worth UAH 19 million and false information worth UAH 44 million
17:30
NACP presented Methodological Recommendations on Building Integrity in Higher Education Institutions
21.05.2025
13:02
Anti-corruption expertise in the defence sector: NACP recommendations ensured compliance with NATO international standards
20.05.2025
18:15
Civil forfeiture: 19.7 million may be confiscated from a Kyiv City Council deputy based on NACP materials
18:00
Almost 150 political parties failed to submit reports for the first quarter of 2025
17:01
Civil forfeiture: court confiscated UAH 3.3 million from Kyiv National Police official to the state based on NACP materials
15:03
In 2023, the number of court decisions on corruption offences increased by 40% - NACP report
16.05.2025
16:15
Civil forfeiture: more than UAH 5.3 million may be confiscated from the family of the former head of the Odesa Tax Office
14:18
Subvention for the creation of educational space in schools: thanks to the consideration of NACP recommendations, a potential corruption scheme has been eliminated
15.05.2025
13:00
Authorisation to conduct customs brokerage activities: corruption schemes eliminated thanks to consideration of NACP recommendations
12:00
Full audits of declarations of two directors of Kharkiv municipal enterprises: inaccurate information worth over UAH 14 million revealed
14.05.2025
12:41
Conflict of interest: criminal proceedings based on materials provided by NACP, substantiated conclusions and protocols
Чат-бот Telegram
contact center
Чат-бот Telegram
Contacts
+38 (044) 200-06-94 info@nazk.gov.ua
працює з 9:00 до 18:00
Технічна підтримка
support@nazk.gov.ua