NACP NACP
A-
A
A+
A
A
Звичайна версія сайту

Regarding the letter from the Presidents of the Venice Commission and GRECO to the Chairman of the Verkhovna Rada on the constitutional crisis in Ukraine

01.11.2020
Regarding the letter from the Presidents of the Venice Commission and GRECO to the Chairman of the Verkhovna Rada on the constitutional crisis in Ukraine
Yesterday, October 31, the Council of Europe published an official letter from the President of the Group of States against Corruption (GRECO) Marin Mrčela and the President of the Venice Commission Gianni Buquicchio to the Speaker of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Dmytro Razumkov regarding the last ruling of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (CCU).   When deciding on the rapid recovery of the anti-corruption system, all the stakeholders should consider that it is not possible to provide it if the CCU’s ruling remains unchanged. Thus, in this situation it is necessary to consider the following three aspects: 1. In its ruling, the CCU violated the Constitution of Ukraine at least twice:
  • The CCU interfered with the powers of the Parliament, noting that the establishment of criminal liability for declaring knowingly inaccurate information, as well as intentional failure to submit a declaration is an excessive punishment for committing these offenses. According to the Constitution of Ukraine, only the legislative branch of government can determine which action should be considered as a crime.
This means that it is impossible to restore criminal liability for declaring inaccurate information and restore the equality of all branches of government by adopting a new law. Any law that would return criminal liability should automatically be considered unconstitutional, taking into account the ruling of the CCU.
  • According to the Constitution, all branches of government should act exclusively within their powers, in the manner and on the grounds provided by the Constitution itself and the laws of Ukraine.
According to the Constitution and laws of Ukraine, the CCU could issue a ruling only within the provisions of the legislation on the prevention of corruption, which were challenged in the constitutional petition. However, the judges violated the requirements of the Constitution and canceled the provisions of the Law of Ukraine “On Prevention of Corruption”, which were not challenged in the constitutional petition of the 47 members of Parliament. 2. The fundamental principles of law prohibit being a judge in one’s own cause. Some of the judges acted in their own interests while considering the case.  Three judges – Volodymyr Moysyk, Ihor Slidenko, and Iryna Zavhorodnia – could be brought to administrative and criminal responsibility by the canceled legal provisions. They were aware of this fact, however, did not file an objection and canceled the mentioned provisions. On the day when the ruling was issued, the National Agency on Corruption Prevention (NACP) announced that the other judge – Serhii Holovatyi – did not declare the property worth  UAH 3.6 million (~$126,500). He also was aware of this fact at the time of participation in the hearing. By issuing the ruling, the CCU suspended the work of the NAPC, revoking its powers, and allowing the thousands of other public officials to avoid the responsibility. 3. The CCU noted that NACP should not be responsible for monitoring judges’ filling the declarations and conflicts of interest on the same grounds as it does with other public officials. This contradicts the previous conclusions of the Venice Commission on a similar issue. In the opinion on the amendments to the judicial code and some other laws in Armenia, the Venice Commission notes that the verification of judges’ declarations by a body outside the judiciary is a better solution than the development of a special body within the judiciary. “Two solutions are possible in this respect: either to create a special body within the judiciary responsible for checking financial declarations of judges or to entrust this task to an external body which deals with the declarations of all public officials. The first solution is better for judicial independence but lacks transparency, which may give rise to a corporatist behaviour. So, the drafters of the Package preferred the second model: it is the CPC which checks the financial declarations of judges on an equal footing with other State officials and which has now the power to start disciplinary proceedings against judges”, the opinion says. It should be added that in its reports GRECO positively assesses the Ukrainian declaration system. “GRECO appreciates that legal and regulatory measures have been taken to improve the control of financial declarations and to provide for appeal channels”, GRECO notes in its Fourth Round Compliance Report on Ukraine. “It is also positive that illicit enrichment has been re-criminalised…”, the Report says. Although GRECO’s compliance reports have a special section called  “Corruption prevention in respect of judges”, there are no recommendations for setting up a separate body to collect, store and verify their declarations.
Regarding the letter from the Presidents of the Venice Commission and GRECO to the Chairman of the Verkhovna Rada on the constitutional crisis in Ukraine

Latest News

16.09.2025
18:45
Tax reform: implementation of anti-corruption mechanisms discussed at NACP
16:06
Anti-Corruption Expertise: NACP provided recommendations to eliminate corruption risks in the areas of housing for internally displaced persons, property relations and reintegration of defenders
15.09.2025
14:30
The Government approved three anti-corruption draft laws: NACP special verifications, civil confiscation in HACC, amendments to the Code of Administrative Offenses and the Criminal Procedure Code
12.09.2025
18:00
Failure to declare property worth over UAH 3.1 million: as a result of a full audit, the case against the energy supervision inspector has been referred to court
15:46
Civil confiscation of UAH 3.2 million from the Chief Sanitary Doctor of Ukraine: results of the full declaration audit
15:30
Anti-Corruption Expertise: NACP Joined the Implementation of a Unified Standard and Remote Procedure for the Military Medical Commission
15:30
Full audits of declarations for August 2025: NACP detected violations exceeding UAH 337 million
11.09.2025
16:30
Full audits: NACP found false information worth over UAH 3.1 million in the declaration of the former head of the regional service center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs
15:00
Lifestyle monitoring: UAH 7 million may be recovered to the state budget from the former head of the capital's district administration
11:00
Lifestyle monitoring: over UAH 8 million could be seized from an official of the Donetsk State Environmental Inspectorate in favor of the state
09.09.2025
15:00
Disillusionment, information attacks and attention to the authorities: how Ukrainian media and social networks covered the topic of corruption in the second quarter of 2025
09:59
NACP statement on certain results of lifestyle monitoring and possible impact on the Agency’s activities
08.09.2025
16:45
Lifestyle monitoring: UAH 8.6 million could be confiscated from an official of the Ministry of Internal Affairs Service Center in favor of the state
16:00
Conflict of interest: a protocol against a judge, substantiated conclusions regarding Kyiv City State Administration officials and disciplinary actions in August
15:15
NACP has launched the development of a new Communication Strategy in the field of preventing and combating corruption with the involvement of key stakeholders
05.09.2025
11:30
Two years of operation of the Whistleblower reporting portal: outcomes, challenges and prospects
04.09.2025
18:00
Full audit of declarations: a case concerning an official of the State Regulatory Service has been referred to court for false declaration
16:47
Lifestyle monitoring: court seized the property of a district state administration official in Kyiv - a business-class apartment and millions in bank accounts
02.09.2025
15:20
Government bodies have implemented nearly 46% of the measures outlined in the State Anti-Corruption Program
01.09.2025
18:30
“From today, lobbyists must either operate openly and honestly, or they have no right to influence government decisions,” says Viktor Pavlushchyk on the launch of the lobbying institute.
Чат-бот Telegram
contact center
Чат-бот Telegram
Contacts
+38 (044) 200-06-94 info@nazk.gov.ua
працює з 9:00 до 18:00
Технічна підтримка
support@nazk.gov.ua